The Two-Year Rule
Removing the Conditional Status of Your Green Card
Getting a green card (Permanent Residence Card) based on marriage to a U.S citizen is a large step in the process of permanent residence, but it is not the final step. If the marriage is less than two years old, the green card is typically “conditional” and the marriage must be re-evaluated before residence is finally made permanent. The process is called a Petition to Remove Conditions on Residence, and must be completed during the ninety days immediately prior to the second anniversary of the date you were granted conditional residence status. You will know when this is by looking at the date on your conditional Permanent Resident Card next to the “EXPIRES” notation. You have to file your petition in the ninety days before the EXPIRES date on your card.
If you are required to file the Petition to Remove Conditions, but do not do so, the consequences can be severe. If the petition is not filed on time, your permanent residence will be considered revoked as of the date your two-year green card expires. At that point you are vulnerable to removal, or deportation.
In most cases the petition process is fairly straightforward. If the marriage has been successful and couple is still married, they will file the petition jointly, and show evidence that their marriage is genuine. This is essentially the same type of evidence used to establish the marriage in the first place (showing lawful marriage documents, evidence of joint accounts, cohabitation, children born to the marriage, etc.), but should be updated up through to the present.
What if You Divorce Your U.S. Citizen Spouse?
Things get more complicated when the marriage has not been successful and separation or divorce are part of the picture. If the breakdown of the marriage looks to be permanent, the first question may be whether the foreign national spouse is ready to give up the marriage and also give up residing in the U.S. In many cases this is neither desirable (for example, where there may be child custody issues) or practical (for example, where the foreign national spouse is involved in an ongoing career or educational program).
The simple fact is that many marriages in our modern world do not last “til death do us part” and some of these do not last through the first two years. It is important to know that the re-evaluation of the marriage for immigration purposes is not (and should not be) aimed at determining if the couple has managed to make a long-term success of their marriage. The sole purpose of the review is to confirm that the marriage was originally entered into in good faith, and not for the purposes of evading the U.S. immigration laws. In other words, if the couple, at the initiation of the marriage, intended in good faith to make a life together, a later separation or divorce does not change the fact that it was a good marriage at the beginning. And if the marriage was good at the beginning, no marriage fraud exists, and there should be no insurmountable impediment to having the conditions removed from permanent residence.
Filing for a ‘Good Faith’ Waiver
The immigration rules provide various ways to accomplish this, and these include four possible waivers of the joint filing requirement. The most commonly used waiver is called the “Good Faith Waiver” and it simply states that the foreign national spouse entered the marriage in good faith, but the marriage was later terminated due to divorce or annulment. The other waivers cover situations where the U.S citizen spouse dies before the two year period, where there has been battering or extreme cruelty, and where extreme hardship will result from the loss of permanent residence.
Although the Good Faith Waiver is most commonly used, and looks like a straightforward solution, it also has some complications. Notice that the wording says that the marriage “was later terminated” – the immigration service has long taken the view that this means the divorce must be final before the waiver may be applied for. If the couple was separated but not yet divorced, or if the divorce had been filed but not finalized, no waiver was deemed available, and the likely result would have been a denial of the petition.
It seems plain that this could lead to an uneven distribution of power in any divorce proceeding, where a U.S. spouse could leverage control over the timing of the proceedings, or whether the proceedings would be uncontested or hard fought, to the disadvantage of a foreign spouse who wants (or needs) to retain U.S. residence. It does not take a leap of imagination to foresee issues such as property division or child custody being distorted in the process.
A recent policy development has provided a partial solution to this dilemma, and a procedure is now in place to allow for filing for the good faith waiver even though the divorce is not yet final. An extension of time may be afforded to the petitioner on request, and a final divorce document may be filed later. If this is relevant to your situation, you should be very sure you understand the requirements and timeline of this approach before going forward.
Contact Migration Counsel using the contact form and we will get back to you within one business day, or call us at 808-695-3560 to arrange a FREE no-obligation consultation on any immigration question you might have.
The information presented here is intended to be general in nature, and should not be relied upon as legal advice.